| 2014 | Brandon Kasberg | Mentor High School | Cleveland Ohio | Ohio Northern University |
| 2014 | Tyler Zaletel | Perry High School | Cleveland Ohio | Westminster College |
| 2014 | Brett Davies | Eastlake North High School | Cleveland Ohio | Thiel College |
| 2014 | Cody Ewing | Perry High School | Cleveland Ohio | Thiel College |
| 2015 | Reece Albright | North Royalton High School | Cleveland Ohio | Baldwin Wallace University |
| 2015 | Scott Barnum | Avon High School | Cleveland Ohio | Notre Dame College |
| 2015 | Nathan Rearick | Massillon High School | Canton Ohio | Notre Dame College |
| 2015 | Ricky Kemp | Brunswick High School | Cleveland Ohio | Cuyahoga Community College |
| 2015 | Tommy Folan | Brunswick High School | Cleveland Ohio | Cuyahoga Community College |
| 2015 | Adam Dennison | Wadsworth High School | Cleveland Ohio | Wheeling Jesuit |
| 2015 | Tyler Thompson | Mentor High School | Cleveland Ohio | Otterbein University |
| 2015 | Sam Fuller | St. Ignatius High School | Cleveland Ohio | St. Bonaventure University |
| 2016 | Kenny Wells | Cloverleaf High School | Cleveland Ohio | Atlanta Braves (2019) |
| 2016 | Chad Mathus | Massillon High School | Canton Ohio | West Liberty University |
| 2016 | Jared Spencer | Field High School | Akron Ohio | Marietta College |
| 2016 | Mike Mathieu | Massillon High School | Canton Ohio | Malone College |
| 2016 | Ross Thompson | Wadsworth High School | Cleveland Ohio | Heidelberg University |
| 2016 | Cameron Deemer | Wadsworth High School | Cleveland Ohio | Heidelberg University |
| 2016 | Alex Scarrow | Wadsworth High School | Cleveland Ohio | Toccoa Falls College |
| 2016 | Noah Brooks | CVCA High School | Cleveland Ohio | Spring Arbor University |
| 2016 | Kyle Paulic | Willoughby High School | Cleveland Ohio | Mount Union University |
| 2016 | Adam Cerar | Lake Catholic High School | Cleveland Ohio | Chatham University |
| 2016 | Anthony Charles | Hawken High School | Cleveland Ohio | Cornell University |
| 2016 | George Asudorian | St. Ignatius High School | Cleveland Ohio | College of Charleston |
| 2016 | Jonathan Conckle | Massillon High School | Canton Ohio | Ohio Dominican University |
| 2017 | Squire Chapman | Mentor High School | Cleveland Ohio | Tiffin University |
| 2017 | Kurtis Farley | St. Edward High School | Cleveland Ohio | Baldwin Wallace University |
| 2017 | Andrai Wright | Clearview High School | Cleveland Ohio | Cuyahoga Community College |
| 2017 | Mark Ochoa | Padua High School | Cleveland Ohio | Heidelberg University |
| 2017 | Myles Burdick | CVCA High School | Cleveland Ohio | Mount Union University |
| 2017 | Nick Cipriani | Notre Dame High School | Cleveland Ohio | Wittenberg University |
| 2017 | Jack Siefert | St. Ignatius High School | Cleveland Ohio | Wittenberg University |
| 2017 | Ted Davis | Madison High School | Cleveland Ohio | Lakeland Community College |
| 2018 | Ryan Schwartz | Solon High School | Cleveland Ohio | Haverford College |
| 2018 | Grant Schwartz | Solon High School | Cleveland Ohio | Haverford College |
| 2018 | Logan Wright | Gilmour High School | Cleveland Ohio | Walsh University |
| 2018 | Chris Rote | Aurora High School | Cleveland Ohio | Otterbein University |
| 2018 | Dominic Prevesk | Willoughby High School | Cleveland Ohio | Cuyahoga Community College |
| 2019 | TIm Munz | Lake Catholic High School | Cleveland Ohio | Geneva College |
| 2019 | Scott Ellsworth | Chardon High School | Cleveland Ohio | Point Park University |
| 2019 | Zach Mitchell | Eastlake North High School | Cleveland Ohio | Marietta College |
| 2019 | John Razzante | Mayfield High School | Cleveland Ohio | Mount Union University |
| 2019 | Dylan Jackson | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Wittenberg University |
| 2019 | Max Monachino | Benediction High School | Cleveland Ohio | Wittenberg University |
| 2019 | Justin Demassimo | Aurora High School | Cleveland Ohio | Lakeland Community College |
| 2019 | Bryan Casey | Mentor High School | Cleveland Ohio | Lakeland Community College |
| 2019 | Justin Laley | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Lakeland Community College |
| 2019 | Seth Higham | Eastlake High School | Cleveland Ohio | Lakeland Community College |
| 2020 | Tyler Horvath | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Michigan State University |
| 2020 | Zach Carinci | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Case Western Reserve University |
| 2020 | Nick Bonnizzio | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Marietta College |
| 2020 | Will Keefe | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Marietta College |
| 2020 | Matt Kahn | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Marietta College |
| 2020 | Joey Procop | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Cuyahoga Community College |
| 2020 | AJ Zigman | Twinsburg High School | Cleveland Ohio | Mount Union University |
| 2020 | Alex Moscal | Notre Dame High School | Cleveland Ohio | North Carolina Wesleyan College |
| 2020 | John Sharp | Notre Dame High School | Cleveland Ohio | Allegheny College |
| 2020 | Tyler Tierno | Lake Catholic High School | Cleveland Ohio | Ohio Northern University |
| 2020 | Jake Crouch | Mayfield High School | Cleveland Ohio | Ohio University |
| 2020 | Jackson Shorter | Charles F Brush High School | Cleveland Ohio | Lakeland Community College |
| 2021 | Nathan Smith | Perry High School | Cleveland Ohio | Jackson State Community College |
| 2022 | Mitch Szymczak | Strongsville High School | Cleveland Ohio | Lake Erie College |
| 2022 | Nathan Bias | Ironton High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Rio Grande University |
| 2022 | Carter Kocic | | Cleveland Ohio | Youngstown State University |
| 2022 | Max Stewart | Batavia High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Earlham University |
| 2022 | Andrew Lang | Archbishop Moeller High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Rose Hulman College |
| 2023 | Jeremiah Atwell | Willoughby High School | Cleveland Ohio | St. Bonaventure University |
| 2023 | Ty Blackburn | St. Francis High School | Columbus Ohio | Chatham University |
| 2023 | Chris Slatt | | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | Seton Hill University |
| 2023 | Zack Maden | Lake Catholic High School | Cleveland Ohio | Marietta College |
| 2023 | Nathan Hickey | St. Francis High School | Columbus Ohio | Taylor University |
| 2023 | Floyd McKenna | | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | Lake Erie College |
| 2023 | Ryan Cathey | Loveland High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Tusculum University |
| 2023 | Mike Rodrigues | Sharon High School | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | Youngstown State University |
| 2023 | Adam Salesky | Willoughby High School | Cleveland Ohio | Cuyahoga Community College |
| 2024 | Tyler Heflin | Archbishop Moeller High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Youngstown State University |
| 2024 | Walker Landrum | Corbin High School | Corbin Kentucky | Morehead State University |
| 2024 | Evan Scott | Archbishop Moeller High School | Cincinnati Ohio | University of Maine |
| 2024 | Alex Bashardast | Archbishop Moeller High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Longwood University |
| 2024 | Henleigh Lopez | Archbishop Moeller High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Centre University |
| 2024 | Ethan Minerva | Hempfield High School | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | California University of PA |
| 2024 | Shea Arkenburg | Geneva High School | Cleveland Ohio | Lake Erie College |
| 2024 | Parker Eliff | | Cincinnati Ohio | Ashland University |
| 2024 | Gary Hills | McDowell High School | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | Mount Union University |
| 2024 | Carter Swanson | McDowell High School | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | Ohio Northern University |
| 2024 | Alex Conrad | Walnut Hills High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Lincoln Trail College |
| 2024 | Evan Tice | Liverpool High School | Cleveland Ohio | Mercyhurst University |
| 2025 | Carter Phillips | Mason High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Lake Erie College |
| 2025 | Ben Hershey | West Jessamine High School | Cincinnati Ohio | Midway University |
| 2025 | Collin Yeager | Canon McMillan | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | Gannon University |
| 2025 | Ethan Bechtold | Mcdowell High School | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | University of Charleston WV |
| 2026 | MJ Marushak | Canon McMillan | Pittsburgh Pennsylvania | Ohio University |
